2,790,154 comments · 15 communities · two years
The internet’s longest argument about dinner, measured
Vegans, ex-vegans, anti-vegans and carnivores have been arguing on Reddit for as long as there has been a Reddit. This is a count of what 238,981 of them wrote between August 2024 to September 2026: the reasons they gave, the numbers they reported, the people they quoted and the lines they crossed.
Six in ten comments come from vegan communities, a quarter from their opponents
Each square is 5,000 comments · 2,790,154 comments in the archive, by camp
The findings
Each chapter takes one question the archive can answer, shows the count, and says what the count can’t tell you.
The first chapters are being published now. Check back shortly.
The fifteen communities
Four camps: vegan communities, the ex-vegan, anti-vegan and carnivore opposition, vegan satire, and the philosophy neighbours, where the argument stops being about food.
| Community | What it is | Comments | Posts | People commenting |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| r/vegan | The main vegan community on Reddit | 1,131,365 | 26,193 | 100,237 |
| r/carnivorediet | The all-meat diet | 425,495 | 20,091 | 29,499 |
| r/VeganDE | German-language vegan community | 386,460 | 13,969 | 41,664 |
| r/antinatalism | The view that creating new life is wrong | 293,379 | 10,857 | 37,781 |
| r/exvegans | Former vegans and vegetarians | 174,343 | 3,831 | 19,297 |
| r/veganuk | Veganism in the United Kingdom | 156,867 | 7,783 | 12,683 |
| r/vegancirclejerk | Satire by hard-line vegans | 81,595 | 7,017 | 8,073 |
| r/AntiVegan | Opposition to veganism | 41,066 | 2,269 | 3,989 |
| r/Vystopia | Vegans coping with a non-vegan world | 26,887 | 2,142 | 3,333 |
| r/animalhaters | Screenshots of people rationalising harm to animals | 22,400 | 2,097 | 1,701 |
| r/VeganActivism | Animal-rights activism and organising | 19,248 | 2,831 | 3,420 |
| r/vegancirclejerkchat | Serious talk among the circlejerk crowd | 17,665 | 777 | 3,185 |
| r/circlesnip | Antinatalism fused with abolitionist veganism | 7,320 | 830 | 1,262 |
| r/cateatingvegans | Absurdist satire ("vegans who eat cats") | 5,994 | 1,042 | 1,865 |
| r/aponism | A small secular philosophy of "absence of pain" | 70 | 26 | 30 |
Counts are what the archive holds for August 2024 to September 2026, after removing automated accounts and moderator-removed items. Communities enter the archive on different dates, so sizes are not a ranking of real-world activity. See Methods.
What this is
Forked describes what people wrote in fifteen public communities over two years. It counts carefully, shows its denominators, and quotes people in their own words without naming them.
It is not a survey, and it is not a study of health. People who post are not a random sample of vegans, ex-vegans or anyone else, and a lab value typed into a comment box is not a lab report. Where published research exists, the chapters point to it. Where the archive can’t answer a question, they say so.