How it was done
How Forked counts, and where it can’t
What is in the archive, what was left out, how text was turned into numbers, and the limits you should keep in mind while reading every chapter.
The short version
- The archive holds 2,790,154 comments and 101,755 posts from 15 public Reddit communities, written by about 238,981 people between August 2024 and 28 September 2026.
- It describes what people wrote. It is not a survey: people who post are not a random sample of vegans, ex-vegans, carnivore dieters or anyone else.
- Every text measure was checked by reading samples, and every chapter’s headline numbers were recomputed independently before publication.
- Nobody is named. Quotes are verbatim, short, and carry only the community, the month and the score.
What is in the archive
Forked is built on an archive of public posts and comments from fifteen Reddit communities that argue about veganism from every direction: the main vegan forums in English and German, the satire boards that orbit them, the ex-vegan and anti-vegan forums, the all-meat diet community, and three philosophy communities where the argument stops being about dinner.
The chapters group them into four camps. The grouping is a reading aid. It does not mean everyone in a community thinks alike, and one of the findings is how many people in each community come from somewhere else.
| Community | Camp | Comments | In the archive from |
|---|---|---|---|
| r/vegan | Vegan | 1,131,365 | September 2024 |
| r/carnivorediet | Opposition | 425,495 | November 2024 |
| r/VeganDE | Vegan | 386,460 | October 2024 |
| r/antinatalism | Philosophy | 293,379 | December 2024 |
| r/exvegans | Opposition | 174,343 | September 2024 |
| r/veganuk | Vegan | 156,867 | October 2024 |
| r/vegancirclejerk | Vegan satire | 81,595 | August 2024 |
| r/AntiVegan | Opposition | 41,066 | September 2024 |
| r/Vystopia | Vegan | 26,887 | September 2024 |
| r/animalhaters | Vegan satire | 22,400 | August 2024 |
| r/VeganActivism | Vegan | 19,248 | September 2024 |
| r/vegancirclejerkchat | Vegan satire | 17,665 | August 2024 |
| r/circlesnip | Philosophy | 7,320 | August 2024 |
| r/cateatingvegans | Vegan satire | 5,994 | September 2024 |
| r/aponism | Philosophy | 70 | April 2025 |
Coverage is uneven, so the chapters use rates
Communities enter the archive on different dates: the satire boards in August 2024, r/vegan and the ex-vegan forums in late September 2024, the UK and German communities in October, r/carnivorediet in late November and r/antinatalism in December. March and April 2025 are only partly covered. And within any thread, not every comment is guaranteed to be present.
That makes raw volume over time a poor guide to how busy these places really were. The chapters therefore lean on things that survive uneven coverage: shares, rates per 1,000 or 10,000 comments, comparisons within the same month, and cohorts followed forward from a known start.
The archive is thinner in spring 2025 because coverage was partial
Comments in the archive per month, thousands, by camp
The shaded span marks partial coverage. Counts exclude automated accounts and moderator-removed comments.
What was left out
- Automated accounts. Comments from moderation tools, reminder services and other automated accounts were removed — about 65,000 comments, most of them stock moderator notices.
- Removed and deleted items. Comments removed by moderators, and anything whose text had been deleted, are excluded from every analysis and are never quoted. Removal flags exist for seven of the fifteen communities; for the rest, removal is unknown rather than zero.
- Official moderator statements (comments posted in a moderator capacity) are excluded from text measures.
- r/aponism is in the archive but too small (70 comments) to support statistics; it appears only in totals.
How text became numbers
Most figures on this site count how often something is said: a reason, a symptom, an argument, a brand, a name. The method is deliberately plain.
- Rules, then reading. Each measure starts as a written rule — patterns of words — and is then tested by pulling random matches and reading them. Rules that caught the wrong thing (a “lion” inside “million”, a vegan quoting an argument in order to mock it) were fixed or dropped. Each chapter’s method note reports the share of sampled matches that were correct.
- Hand coding where rules fail. Questions such as “why did this person stop being vegan?” were answered by reading and coding posts against a written codebook, not by keyword.
- Sincere or sarcastic? The satire communities voice their opponents’ arguments as jokes. Wherever that matters, mentions were sampled and split into sincere use and quotation or mockery.
- Scores are the net votes a post or comment had roughly a day after it was written. Communities differ enormously in size and voting habits, so scores are compared within a community (as percentiles), never across.
- German. r/VeganDE is German-language. English word rules do not transfer, so it is either analysed with German rules or left out, and each chapter says which.
- Reading at scale. Reading and coding thousands of posts was done with the help of AI language models working from written codebooks. Their output was checked against samples, and each chapter reports how often the rules were right.
- Independent re-derivation. Before publication, each chapter’s headline numbers were recomputed from scratch in a separate pass that also tried to break the method. Findings that did not survive were corrected, softened or cut.
Reading the results with care
Five things to keep in mind
1. Self-selection. People who post in r/exvegans are people who chose to tell a story about quitting. People who post lab results are people who had lab results worth posting. None of this estimates how common anything is among vegans, former vegans or carnivore dieters in general.
2. Self-report. A number typed into a comment is not a medical record. People misremember, round, and report what supports their story.
3. No cause and effect. “People who quit often mention fatigue” is a statement about what people write. It is not evidence about what a diet does.
4. One platform, fifteen rooms. Activity elsewhere — other subreddits, other sites, offline — is invisible here. Someone who “appears” in a community may have been there for years.
5. Not advice. Nothing on this site is medical or nutritional advice.
Quotes and privacy
Quotes are verbatim excerpts, trimmed with an ellipsis where needed, and attributed only by community, month and score. No usernames appear anywhere on the site, there are no per-person statistics, and no figure is built to single anyone out. Quotes that would reveal identifying details, and anything touching on self-harm or disordered eating, were excluded. Public figures — authors, doctors, broadcasters, brands — are named where the communities discuss them.
Related research
Forked is not the first attempt to study these arguments, though it is, as far as we could find, the first to look at this many communities side by side. For context:
- Faunalytics (2014) surveyed 11,399 US adults and found far more former vegetarians and vegans (1,166) than current ones (221) — the origin of the often-quoted “84% give it up”. A third of the former group had lasted three months or less.
- Lennerz and colleagues (2021) surveyed 2,029 adults eating a carnivore diet, recruited through social media. They reported high satisfaction and a median LDL cholesterol of 172 mg/dL among the 462 who gave current values.
- Gregson, Piazza and Boyd (2022) analysed five years of r/AntiVegan — about 49,000 posts from 3,819 users — and found most participants posted once and left.
Colophon
Charts are drawn with D3. Text is set in Fraunces and Inter. The color palette was tested for color-blind legibility in both light and dark modes; every chart has a table view for the underlying numbers.